Underpayments 3 min read
Check the allowed amount, not the payment
Every payment looks short against your fee schedule. Real underpayments hide in the allowed amount.
Most practices that try to check their insurance payments start in the obvious place: the deposit. The payer paid $78 for a 99214, the contract says $112, so the payer owes $34. Do that for a month of claims and it looks as if every payer is underpaying every visit.
They are not. The deposit is the wrong number to compare, and the real shortfalls, which are usually smaller and far more consistent, are hiding one line higher.
How a payment breaks down
Every line on a remittance, the 835 file or paper EOB your payers send back, moves through the same steps:
- Billed charge. What your practice charged, from your own price list.
- Contractual adjustment. The part the payer will not pay because of your contract, reported as
CO-45. You cannot bill the patient for it. - Allowed amount. The charge minus the contractual adjustment: what the payer agreed this visit was worth.
- Patient responsibility. The deductible (
PR-1), coinsurance (PR-2) and copay (PR-3). The patient owes these, not the payer. - Payment. What is left: the allowed amount minus the patient's share.
The payment is smaller than the allowed amount whenever the patient owes anything. Early in the year, when deductibles reset, it can be zero on a claim that was processed perfectly.
One claim, compared both ways
Here is a single 99214 from a practice whose contract with the payer says $112.00. The numbers are illustrative.
| Line on the remittance | Amount |
|---|---|
| Billed charge | $180.00 |
| Contractual adjustment (CO-45) | −$77.00 |
| Allowed amount | $103.00 |
| Copay (PR-3) | −$25.00 |
| Payment | $78.00 |
Compared with the payment, the claim looks $34.00 short. But $25.00 of that is the patient's copay, which the payer was never going to pay. Compared with the allowed amount, the shortfall is $9.00: the payer allowed $103.00 where the contract says $112.00.
That $9.00 is the underpayment, and you can only see it by looking at the allowed amount.
Where the shortfall hides
Notice where the missing $9.00 went. The contractual adjustment is $77.00. Had the payer used the contracted rate, it would have been $68.00. The difference was folded into a line that every biller is trained to write off without a second look.
That is why underpayments survive for months. Nothing on the remittance says "underpaid". The claim is marked paid, the adjustment looks routine, and the deposit is close enough to what the practice usually receives.
Why patterns matter more than claims
Nine dollars is not worth an afternoon on the phone. But underpayments are rarely one-off mistakes. They are usually a rule in the payer's system: a rate increase that was never loaded, an old fee schedule still in place for one location, a code paid at last year's rate.
So the same shortfall repeats on every visit with that code. A payer that paid 99214 $9.00 short on 88 visits since its July rate increase owes $792.00, and will keep underpaying until someone shows it the contract. Grouping shortfalls by payer, code and start date turns a pile of small differences into one clear request.
Not every lower allowed amount is an underpayment. Multiple procedures on the same day, modifiers and the place of service can all lower what a contract pays, by the contract's own terms. Check those rules before you ask a payer to reprocess.
What to do about it
- Confirm the rate. Find the contracted rate for that payer, code and date of service, including any amendment that changed it.
- Find the pattern. Look for the same payer and code on other claims, and note when the shortfall started.
- Ask for reprocessing. Send the payer's provider relations team the affected claims, the contract excerpt and the effective date of the rate, and ask them to reprocess at the contracted rate and fix the rate in their system.
- Watch the next remittances. The fix is only real once new claims come back at the right rate.
Varnola does all four for every clinic it bills for. Every paid line is checked against your contracted rate for that payer and code, repeated shortfalls are grouped into patterns with what each one adds up to, and the reprocessing request goes to the payer with the evidence attached. If you have no rate sheet to hand, we work out your rates from your own payment history for you to confirm.